Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Tactical Retreat of Shaolin Kungfu

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The Tactical Retreat of Shaolin Kungfu

    The recent discussions in the Taijiquan forum about moving backwards got me thinking. I thought long and hard about whether or not to write this article, thereby revealing what is considered to be a Shaolin "secret,” but I finally decided to be as open here as my Sifu has always been with me. As Sifu says, "We have so many secrets, we can afford to be generous.”

    The tactic I will be describing in this article is actually a grouping of tactics that share a similar theme. The general theme is that of a "retreat" -- i.e. moving or shifting backwards. For the sake of this article, I am calling this theme the "Tactical Retreat of Shaolin Kungfu." This term is of my own invention and will not be found in any of Sifu’s other articles.

    The Marvelous
    One of the hallmarks of Shaolin Kungfu is what Sifu calls "the Marvelous." A Shaolin axiom states:
    Strength cannot match techniques; techniques cannot match force; force cannot match speed; and speed cannot match the marvelous.
    But what does marvelous mean? To quote Sifu, it means that:
    ...the response is so superb, usually with an element of surprise, that the opponent himself cannot help marveling with awe and admiration at it.... The marvelous response gives a sense of being 'just right' in all aspects, though it may be directly related to one particular aspect, like that of techniques, force, speed, or other factors.
    The Marvelous may seem like something only for masters, but even relative beginners can experience pieces of it. When following a systematic sparring methodology, bits and pieces of the Marvelous will begin to come out naturally. They may not be the same as a master’s Marvelous techniques, just as a beginner will not experience the same internal force as a master, but that does not mean a beginner is not capable of experiencing some internal force or pieces of the Marvelous.

    Many of us in Shaolin Wahnam have already experienced the Marvelous in the spontaneous application of techniques during sequence sparring. I’m sure many of you have had the thought, “Wow, how did I do that?” Your response was so natural and fluid that you even surprised yourself!

    The concept of the Marvelous is important for understanding my explanation of the Tactical Retreat. It is also important to have an understanding of the Shaolin Kungfu principles, including:
    • Striking the opponent when his old strength is spent but his new strength has not been created.
    • Starting later but arriving earlier.
    • No defense, direct counter.
    • Signal to the east; strike the west.
    • Avoiding an opponent's strong points; striking the weak ones.
    • Tricking an opponent into advancing without success; striking decisively with just one blow.
    • Attacking the opponent's unexpectedness.
    • Using long to strike short.


    Let's look at a few examples.

    Yin and Yang
    Let’s imagine that I am facing an opponent in friendly sparring. I begin in a right Bow Arrow Stance in the poise pattern Fierce Dragon Crosses Stream (found in Sequences 5 and 6.) See Picture 1 below.

    As I calmly observe my opponent, I try to gauge whether or not he will initiate the attack. In my experience, 30 seconds of patience is often all you need to lure an opponent into initiating an attack. (If he is patient and does not attack, then I might use a ruse and initiate a false attack in order to elicit a response.)

    Let's presume that he initiates. Since I am in a relatively long stance and have 50% of my weight on each leg, some people might assume that I have very little mobility, or in Taijiquan terms, that I have "the weakness of double yang." This kind of thinking usually comes from a lack of experience with genuine Shaolin stances, which are fluid and exceedingly agile.

    For example, even without moving my feet, but simply by using my waist and shifting my weight, I can neutralize many attacks as well as launch my own counter attacks -- and I can do these faster than if I moved my feet!

    It’s important to remember that Yin and Yang apply not only to the left and right feet, but also to the body and hands. In the pattern Fierce Dragon Crosses Stream, my lower body would be Yin (solid and rooted) whereas my upper body would be Yang (active and flexible).

    At higher levels, this Top Yang Bottom Yin is all that a master would need against most opponents. Without moving his feet, he could neutralize and counter hundreds of different attacks in one smooth movement. In Shaolin Kungfu, many Dragon patterns use this kind of movement. Swimming Dragon Plays with Water would be a good example. Green Dragon Shoots Pearl, as seen in Picture 2 and Picture 3, would be another good example.

    In Picture 2, you can see that I have removed the original target from Mike’s reach simply by shifting backwards. I’ve also lured him a bit by neutralizing his taming hand. As you can see, he is reaching with his punch, leaning slightly too far in his stance. In Picture 3, you can see that I have taken advantage and “tamed two with one” while delivering an attack to his head. This would be an example of a tactical retreat that flows smoothly into a counter attack, using the principle of "striking the opponent when his old strength is spent but his new strength has not been created."

    The Simple Retreat
    The previous example is actually quite advanced. For the sake of this article, let’s examine some simpler retreats.

    From the poise Fierce Dragon Crosses Stream, as my opponent initiates his attack, I can simply shift backwards from my Bow Arrow Stance into a False Leg Stance, thereby removing all of his targets. Simple, yes. Unsophisticated, no. It is worthwhile to remember that even the simplest of things, like meditation, can be profound when practiced skillfully.

    With skillful timing, this simple retreat enables us to not only evade an attack, but also to be poised to strike back at the golden opportunity when the opponent's old strength has been spent and his new strength has yet to be created. The False Leg Stance is actually beautiful in its versatility, even when limited to forward and backward movements.

    In Picture 4, you can see that Ronan has retreated backwards to a safe distance from Darryl’s attack. He also “leans” on Darryl’s attack with his Tiger Claw, but even without the lean, he would be relatively safe.

    Many of you have learned this skill in Combat Sequence 1. If you practice it well, you will eventually find that you are able to sense when your opponent’s attack is fully spent, and pounce at the golden opportunity. Then why is it so hard to land a Black Tiger on your opponent (an inch away!!) in this sequence? Because he also knows how to do a Tactical Retreat into the False Leg stance!

    A skill that will make the attack more effective, but which is beyond the scope of this article, is called taming. Those of you familiar with this technique should have no trouble understanding where the skill fits in.

    Six Harmonies
    What if my opponent uses Continuous Punches so skillfully that there is no golden opportunity between his attacks? Or what if I miss the golden opportunity? Since I have already retreated back to a False Leg Stance and have 90% of my weight on my back leg, am I not trapped with no place to go?

    If I am in an awkward stance and have not maintained the Six Harmonies (Liu He), namely Essence, Energy, Mind, Body, Hand, Footwork (Jing Qi Shen2 Shen1 Shou Bu), then yes, I will be trapped. I will have no place to go and I will be in trouble. But if I train systematically to maintain the Six Harmonies not only during form practice, but also during sparring, then I will be able to retreat skillfully. I will also be able to move in any direction with either an attack or a defense, or both.

    If my opponent is using Continuous Punches and I have already retreated a few feet backwards from Bow Arrow to False Leg, he must press his attack forward in order to reach me. In his haste to catch up with me, he must be careful not to fall into my ruse. Remember that my front "false" leg has no weight. Also remember that, unless he is 8 feet tall, my legs are longer than his arms.

    In Picture 5, if you look carefully, you can see that Ronan is about to be hit unawares by Chun Nga’s No Shadow Kick. In this example, Chun Nga is simultaneously using the principles of "Long against Short," "No Defense Direct Counter," and "Starting Later but Arriving Earlier.” In friendly sparring, he would simply tap his foot on Ronan’s abdomen, but in real combat he could easily break a knee or blast Ronan in the groin. Again, we can see how a simple retreat opened the way for a fight-ending counter.

    Direct Counter
    What if my opponent uses a kick, which has more reach? Again, there are many options from both the Bow Arrow and the False Leg Stances, even if we just limit ourselves to purely backwards movement. From either stance, I can retreat to the other stance without stepping backwards. The footwork to go from Bow to False Leg appears in Sequence 1, while the footwork to go from False Leg to Bow appears in Sequence 5.

    The pattern Single Whip Saves the Emperor is a good counter against kicks and can be seen in Picture 6 and Picture 7. Many of us have learned this pattern as a counter against front thrust kicks like White Horse Presents Hoof (Combat Sequence 10), but at higher levels it can be adapted to counter almost any kick, especially if you have some internal force.

    In this example, the principles would be "no defense, direct counter" along with "avoid an opponent's strong points, strike the weak ones." By retreating, we have removed the targets from our opponent, but his leg remains a viable target for our Single Whip. With skillful timing and some force, you can -- from a safe distance -- strike his knee, shin, or ankle with a "sting" that can numb his leg.

    Although only a few of us have enough force to break a leg with one strike, a good "sting" can be enough even in combat. Having had my leg stung by my seniors, I know what it feels like. Maintaining the Six Harmonies when one of your legs has been stung is virtually impossible. As soon as you put that leg down, you are unsteady and vulnerable.

    In conclusion, we have looked at a few of the numerous ways where moving backwards in a tactical manner gives us an advantage to clinch victory. I find it fascinating that some people view moving backwards as a disadvantage in combat. From my perspective, moving backwards is not only an advantage -- it can be a fight-ending tactic. Of course, the key is to retreat skillfully.
    Last edited by Antonius; 21 December 2004, 05:29 PM.
    Sifu Anthony Korahais
    www.FlowingZen.com
    (Click here to learn more about me.)

  • #2
    And the rest of the pictures:
    Sifu Anthony Korahais
    www.FlowingZen.com
    (Click here to learn more about me.)

    Comment


    • #3
      Anthonius,

      Thank you very, very much for sharing your knowledge and expertise. This is certainly a posting to study, and hopefully put into practice.

      Many Thanks,
      Chris.

      Comment


      • #4
        Thanks, Chris. Glad you liked it.

        If you are practicing Sifu's combat sequences, then you are already putting the Tactical Retreat into practice.

        Happy practicing.
        Sifu Anthony Korahais
        www.FlowingZen.com
        (Click here to learn more about me.)

        Comment


        • #5
          I just found this lovely picture of Sifu doing the pattern Fierce Dragon Crosses Stream. It's a much better example than mine. For one thing, he's not wearing shorts.

          Enjoy.
          Sifu Anthony Korahais
          www.FlowingZen.com
          (Click here to learn more about me.)

          Comment


          • #6
            Anthony,

            Thanks for that incredible post. Thanks also for the picture of Sifu performing that pattern ..... means I don't have to look at your hairy legs too much

            There is so much information in your article and obviously also so much experience. It certainly makes the less experienced of us (like me) think and re-evaluate much of what has been learned.

            I, for one, would find it extremely useful if you could expand on some of the points you made. As an example, you wrote
            At higher levels, this Top Yang Bottom Yin is all that a master would need against most opponents. Without moving his feet, he could neutralize and counter hundreds of different attacks in one smooth movement.
            Could you elaborate further on how this principle "Top Yang Bottom Yin" results in combative advantages. Are there situations where this would actually be a disadvantage?

            Thanks again,
            Andrew
            Sifu Andrew Barnett
            Shaolin Wahnam Switzerland - www.shaolin-wahnam.ch

            Flowing Health GmbH www.flowing-health.ch (Facebook: www.facebook.com/sifuandrew)
            Healing Sessions with Sifu Andrew Barnett - in Switzerland and internationally
            Heilbehandlungen mit Sifu Andrew Barnett - in der Schweiz und International

            Comment


            • #7
              Anthony, now that things have a least temporarily become a little quieter, do you think you could find a few minutes to post on this thread again. I know you are very busy right now --- so sorry for adding to that load.

              Thanks,
              Andrew
              Sifu Andrew Barnett
              Shaolin Wahnam Switzerland - www.shaolin-wahnam.ch

              Flowing Health GmbH www.flowing-health.ch (Facebook: www.facebook.com/sifuandrew)
              Healing Sessions with Sifu Andrew Barnett - in Switzerland and internationally
              Heilbehandlungen mit Sifu Andrew Barnett - in der Schweiz und International

              Comment


              • #8
                Thanks for remembering, Andrew. I'm still a bit busy, but I'll leave you with something to think about in the meantime:

                There are situations when a tactical retreat would be a disadvantage, not an advantage. Can anyone think of an example?
                Sifu Anthony Korahais
                www.FlowingZen.com
                (Click here to learn more about me.)

                Comment


                • #9
                  when your opponent is off-balance and vunerable?

                  when your opponent grabs hold of you?

                  when fighting multiple opponents?

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Let's assume that:
                    tactical retreat = retreat which brings advantage

                    That being the case, tactically retreating could only be disadvantageous when:
                    a) more advantage could be achieved by not retreating
                    b) incorrect judgement, timing or spacing

                    Andrew
                    Sifu Andrew Barnett
                    Shaolin Wahnam Switzerland - www.shaolin-wahnam.ch

                    Flowing Health GmbH www.flowing-health.ch (Facebook: www.facebook.com/sifuandrew)
                    Healing Sessions with Sifu Andrew Barnett - in Switzerland and internationally
                    Heilbehandlungen mit Sifu Andrew Barnett - in der Schweiz und International

                    Comment


                    • #11
                      Hi everyone !

                      I remember reading in one ( or more ) of Sifu's books that when facing devastating kicks , like a Whirlwind Kick , most people will either block it head on and injure themselves , or they will retreat away from the kick to move themselves out of range .

                      I would say that this is one situation where tactical retreat is not the best option . Although you may not receive the blow , you have not improved your situation either . Sifu said that moves like Repulse Monkey , which involve moving into the opponent and intercepting the attack at its weakest point ( in this case the thigh ) , are better responses .

                      These are my two cents

                      Best Wishes ,
                      Kevin

                      Comment


                      • #12
                        Appropriate and Inappropriate uses of the Tactical Retreat

                        Good answers, everyone. It's nice to see that this thread has encouraged people to do some thinking. There are instances when the Tactical Retreat is inappropriate, but much depends on the specific Tactical Retreat used, as well as the skills in using that technique. Remember that I have used the term Tactical Retreat to include many different techniques.

                        Inappropriate

                        So what are some inappropriate uses?

                        Well, for starters, if your back is up against a wall, then it would be inappropriate to try to use a Simple Retreat. A better choice would be to use Continuous Attacks. A similar topic was discussed here.

                        Similarly, if you are surrounded by multiple opponents, then you must choose your Tactical Retreat carefully. Shifting backwards with the Simple Retreat may get you away from one opponent, but it may also move you right into the hands (or weapon) of another opponent. In this case, some alternative tactics would be: "Back Wall battle, "Dodge Hit battle," "Catch the Leader First," and "Break Through the Weak One".

                        Appropriate

                        On the other hand, Chris' example of an opponent grapping you is not necessarily an inappropriate use. There are many cases when you could use the Simple Retreat or Top Yang Bottom Yin to counter a grab. Those of you who have learned the advanced progressions of Sequence 1 already know how to use the Simple Retreat this way. Those of you who have learned Sequence 17 know how to use Top Yang Bottom Yin in this way.

                        In Sequence 1, if your opponent grabs your Black Tiger with his Single Tiger (Wahnam students -- do not attempt this unless specifically taught by your Sifu), it might seem foolish to retreat. But it is not foolish. This example illustrates the profundity of Shaolin Kungfu. Not only can we still use a Tactical Retreat when grabbed in this situation -- we can use the exact same pattern (Single Tiger) as a counter!

                        Single Tiger can be used as an effective (and beautiful) counter to itself, but only when you have the appropriate skills, as well as some force. If you simply try to jerk your hand back while retreating, your opponent will easily pull you off balance or into his punch. But if you maintain the Six Harmonies and use the tactic "Avoiding an opponent's strong points; striking the weak ones," (note: in this instance, "striking" does not necessarily mean delivering a strike) then you can effectively neutralize your opponent's grab even if he has considerable force. And you can do this while retreating backwards!
                        Last edited by Antonius; 21 December 2004, 03:06 PM.
                        Sifu Anthony Korahais
                        www.FlowingZen.com
                        (Click here to learn more about me.)

                        Comment


                        • #13
                          Excellent -- thanks for taking time out from the "other thread" and exams to post here. When you get some more time (amazing how much time and energy you actually have when considering the other posts, exams, etc. ---- a result of your/our training maybe ?? ) maybe you could elaborate on the other question I noted .... ".... how this principle "Top Yang Bottom Yin" results in combative advantages. Are there situations where this would actually be a disadvantage?"

                          Thanks,
                          Andrew
                          Sifu Andrew Barnett
                          Shaolin Wahnam Switzerland - www.shaolin-wahnam.ch

                          Flowing Health GmbH www.flowing-health.ch (Facebook: www.facebook.com/sifuandrew)
                          Healing Sessions with Sifu Andrew Barnett - in Switzerland and internationally
                          Heilbehandlungen mit Sifu Andrew Barnett - in der Schweiz und International

                          Comment


                          • #14
                            Top Yang Bottom Yin
                            Originally posted by Sifu Wong
                            Looking back at the many sparring sessions and a few real fights in my younger days, I would say that the most crucial factor enabling me to come out of combat unhurt was my stances!
                            We have all heard Sifu talk about the importance of the stances. Many of us know -- from direct (and sometimes grueling) experience -- that he heavily emphasizes stances in his teaching. Many of us have also heard the saying:
                            If you have powerful arms and solid stances, unless your opponent is a master, you have already won three-tenths of the battle before it even begins.
                            Anyone who has sparred with Sifu will have no trouble understanding how a solid stance can bring tremendous advantages in combat. You know how terrifying it is to be completely uprooted by a simple Single Tiger. But there is more to the stances than just being solid.

                            In Shaolin Kungfu, the stances must be alive. This is what I mean by Top Yang Bottom Yin. These stances are not just stable -- they are agile! Many people see deep stances as a hinderance to agility and speed. The opposite is true.

                            Boxing vs. Shaolin

                            Let's compare the example I gave in Picture 2 and Picture 3 to a similar situation in Western Boxing.

                            Many people assume that the Boxer has the advantage of speed because of his agile footwork. It's true that boxers are fast, but there are many disadvantages to their footwork. For starters, it is tactically slower. In the above example, I can swerve away from the attack without moving my feet and swerve back to deliver a strike long before a boxer could bounce away and bounce back.

                            What about Boxers who slip under or around punches? This is a faster tactic, but because of the Boxing stance, it leaves them vulnerable to other attacks. In order to slip a punch in Boxing, you must crouch down or lean to the side, thereby exposing the back of your head as well as your legs to attacks (both illegal moves in Boxing). You are also vulnerable to grappling (also illegal in Boxing).

                            In order to compensate for the weakness in their stance, boxers usually cover their head (hands up near their ears) while slipping punches. That may protect them from fists covered with large gloves, but it will not protect them from the subtle and fast attacks of a Snake Fist or a Tiger Claw -- both of which are possible only with when using Top Yang Bottom Yin.

                            In Shaolin stances -- precisely because the stances are deep and solid -- we can move the upper body in many ways, and we can do it without exposing ourselves. Thus, we can have agility not only in the way we step, but also an entirely different kind of agility from the waist up (Top Yang). Think of a snake coiled and ready to strike. The bottom, coiled half hardly moves (Bottom Yin), but the top half is still incredibly agile (Top Yang).

                            The combination of a rooted stance, waist power, various hand forms, and internal force makes it possible to deliver devastating strikes from many angles without even moving the feet. That is the beauty of Top Yang Bottom Yin -- it maximizes the advantages while minimizing the disadvantages (discussed above). Thanks to Top Yang Bottom Yin, we can be more agile than a Boxer, and we can do it without making ourselves vulnerable to potentially deadly counter attacks.

                            Another disadvantage of the Boxing stance is that bouncing makes your Qi float, thereby making it difficult to differentiate between real and feigned attacks, especially when you add kicks and grappling into the mix. It is impossible to maintain the Six Harmonies while bouncing around. But with Shaolin stances, you can be calm and alert while simultaneously being agile and powerful. This is another aspect of Top Yang Bottom Yin -- the mind (shen) is fresh up top while the Qi is rooted below.

                            Sparring against Magicians and Snakes

                            I remember listening to Ronan talk about his first experience sparring Sifu using Boxing (which he trained from a young age). He said it felt like sparring a magician who could teleport from here to there. Every time Ronan felt like he was about to land a punch, Sifu would be just out of reach. Then Sifu would be on top of him in a flash -- faster than any boxer Ronan had ever seen. Ronan said he felt that Sifu could hit him any time he wanted whereas he was only able to hit air.

                            I had a similar experience when I first sparred Sifu. Although I didn't used Boxing (it was Karate for me back then), I felt that there was something odd about the way he moved. At one point, I really felt like I was fighting a snake. I thought I had him with a chop to his neck, but I only hit air. Just as I expected to hit, I found him coiling back with a Snake Fist slicing across my eyebrows -- a technique the likes of which I had never even imagined in Karate.

                            Sifu was able to do these things because of the principle of Top Yang Bottom Yin.
                            Last edited by Antonius; 24 December 2004, 10:43 PM.
                            Sifu Anthony Korahais
                            www.FlowingZen.com
                            (Click here to learn more about me.)

                            Comment


                            • #15
                              Hi Anthony,

                              Thanks for the lovely post
                              Jeffrey Segal

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X