Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Philosophists cant know 'God'

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Philosophists cant know 'God'

    Hey, some of you know me some of you don't. This is a post about the paradox of life and death and the immortal question 'why', that every intellectual has never satisfied.

    This is for those of you for whom death, infinity, and why, keeps you up at night.

    Because annoying religionists who think faith is self evident don't understand or fail to explain properly thier revelation to those of us who rely on logic. That which we see and cannot achieve as blind faith, ignorance or bliss.

    I'm just gonna describe yesterday.

    I crept in on the theosophist societies book talk day. It was a bit of a surprise. Mostly people were doddery old ladies seeking the romance of foreign enlightenment to fill the gaps their current religion missed. Death like a cold wind, and religion and faith thier house, Theosophy is their polyfilla to keep out the chill they've come to noticed. Organised by a burlesque assertive neo pagan, a gaunt modern hippy, and an ex-catholic nun come primary school teacher type who seemed to be in 'teach the children' mode in book review talk. It was quite amusing. We are all as lost as each other. Some happily, some not so much.

    I did get into a debate with the chief brain (a staunchly conservative looking man, the David Cameron type) and the ex nun type who mentioned the EU. They seem to be of the impression it was the new Soviet union and that we were all going to become oppressed in an unaccountable faceless machine that uses Polish armies to suppress the British and British armies to suppress the Polish ect. That was fun to discuss, most people I hang around with get bored of the politics but for me it's as fun (and important) as football.

    Then once all the people had left I hung around and chatted with the old hippy type who ran, lived in, and was secretary to the Torbay 'Lodge' a greatly peaceable and warm guy called Chris, and a Spanish lady, whose name for the third time I have forgotten. We talked about all sorts, mostly life concepts and where I was and had come from.
    I told them about my fear of death thing at 14 and where it had all led me, and they put in their thoughts on the matter. I showed them some philosophical theories they appeared not to know, and paradoxes, and they countered them and such. It was quite fun. I went in at 3 and went home at 11:30.

    It was really useful because although they may not have realised it, they helped me immensely.

    In many ways we're all as lost as each other, and for that reason, I'm never wowed by spiritualists, or religions. However this fear of death, which still comes every night, drives me to find a way to put it to rest.

    It's basically this realisation about death, and the fact that you are dead for infinity. Then I fear the concept of infinity, how can life be infinite. What's the point if it's infinite? A point in something means a goal, at which you end or start again, but for infinity? whats the point?
    Christianity with heaven, Buddhism with reincarnation all seem to not explain infinity, in fact fundamentally their argument seem flawed because of the nature of the infinite. Judaic, Christian, Islamic God wiping out sinners with the flood. A futile effort when you realise what infinity is. A God would know the futility in 'ridding the world of sin'.
    So this was/is the thought that creeps into my head. The 'why', the 'what's outside of this, what's outside of that then, well what's outside of that?' thought pattern. It's something that cannot be logically put to bed.

    ...and I cannot find faith because I have no faith that anyone else it right either.

    I described faith as being told to crash into a wall with your seat belt on, because someone says the seatbelt will save you.
    Some people accept it, some people never question it, some do and have different ones, but I and (I imagine others) just arent convinced.

    So because I have no faith in what happens after death and the spirituality of man, I find it hard to put the thought and fear to rest without seeming like I'm just ignoring the problem. So infinity and death has a fear in me because my mind cannot comprehend 'why'.

    I told them of Zeno's Paradox of the Tortoise and Achilles. How because of infinity Achilles can never pass the Tortoise. Obviously in reality all he has to do is pass the Tortoise. But with infinity in mind, it should be impossible.
    So it proves the flaw of infinity. The proof of infinity is easy, all you have to do is divide 1 by 3. Or 10 by 3. Or however you choose. The calculator will either say Er, or display 3.333333333333333 and if it had the space it would go on for infinity.

    Then Chris said something in a sentence he was putting forward. Halfway through he said, ".....,your mind is only good for certain things,.......".

    Obviously I thought that was crap, it is by my mind that I comprehend everything. It and all it creates and decides and sees is what is.

    Then I realised that it was completely true.

    Our logical mind. That is to say, that which we work things out with, not the creative part ect. But the Logical part, the bit that dissects arguments and counters information with facts and makes rational judgement, is a calculator.
    This is obvious.

    A calculator cannot cut a cake into three equal pieces.

    Because of 3.33333 recurring it will never find the place to put the knife.

    In that sense, you cannot work out where to cut a cake. The logical mind is doomed to go into overload, its like using tea to make coffee. To cut the cake you must realise that the logical part of your mind will never cut the cake into 3 equal parts, nor is it logically possible to. You have to just cut the cake on creativity and/or faith.

    Therefore the brain can never know the spirit, can never know God, or existence. If they exist or if they don't exist is a futile movement of the brain because what we are trying to look for is what is outside that box, outside that box, outside that box, why, but why, but why.

    If we try to think about why, we will always eventually end up stuck thinking you cant pass the Tortoise or cut the cake.

    So thinking about if and why God exists or the point in life exists is a matter the brain is not capable of knowing because of 3.3333 recurring.

    Anyway that doesn't clear up all the questions but it leads me to feel the answer cannot be thought or logical.

    Pretty eventful day huh.
    sto pro veritate

  • #2
    Hi Sevenhills,

    Interesting post. It sounds like you are in a conundrum that a fair amount of people end up in. You think that the logical mind is all you have to work with. Then you get stuck in an infinite loop, trying to accomplish things with logic that can't be done (like you so nicely explained with the calculator 10/3 example)

    There is more to your mind than the logical mind. There is also an intuitive mind. A part that can just know things, without any logic. This intuitive mind can let your whole mind relax, and you will get better results.

    "I described faith as being told to crash into a wall with your seat belt on, because someone says the seatbelt will save you."
    I personally don't think this is what faith is. To me, faith is understanding Cosmic Law. Spiritual Law. Metaphysical Law. So it isn't something whose value can't be witnessed and assessed by your logical mind. But you would need to suspend your disbelief for long enough to see for yourself.

    Leaning on your logical mind for answers can cause mental tension. If you relax, relax, relax you may be surprised how many answers find there way *to* you. Rather than the other way around.

    All the Best,
    Alex
    "Take a moment to feel how wonderful it feels just to be alive."
    - Sifu

    Comment


    • #3
      I think my new task is to find new equipment. Logical brain just cant do it. this has given me a bit of peace. It's stopped me allowing my mind to try an work out "but why, but why, but why" Now that I can see its limitations, I see that the logical mind isnt the place of answers, its a place for answers for some things. But for others, it just wont work. No one explained it well enough before.
      sto pro veritate

      Comment


      • #4
        Form cannot explain or understand formlessness; that which perceives itself as limited cannot explain nor understand the unlimited.

        When there is experience that both are the same, it gets easier.

        And yes, "relax, relax, relax" is invaluable advice. Now, how to relax?

        Just relax
        When one door closes, another one opens.

        Comment


        • #5
          I got past this problem. Took me a long time but I logically found the path to "God" with total logic. I ended up with three conclusions. Either everything is pointless, science still has to investigate the universe further or there is an experiential plane of existence (enlightenment, heavens etc.) Mathematics is just a language which gives the illusion of infinity. It's like changing different coloured pixels to create thousands of pictures.

          If everything is pointless then there is no point having this conversation so therefore pointlessness is highly illogical. Science having to investigate further to find meaning for our existence is highly unlikely because scientists studies regard us as meaningless anyway so anything derived from science will mean that the meaning of life is outside of our experience. Since we exists experientially the meaning of life has to have something in common with our experience. Therefore experience is significant. It must be more significant then a pointless biological entity creating an experience. The experience itself has to be somehow spiritual. It's a play on words basically. It's like a semantics maze. My logical conclusion in regards to "God" is that it has to be real. All I have to do now is find it and i can't do that thinking.

          You may say whats the point of living forever. Well ironically you will either be dead forever or alive forever. When you are dead forever you won't realise it. However if i was to say that you would live forever happy and content then it's a totally different story. An eternal happy and blissful state is a state of happiness where no other worries can enter because it's a state of happiness and bliss. So both ways your not going to be worried about living forever. You won't be able to contemplate it or you will be unable because your content and happy.
          Last edited by Mbyte; 1 October 2009, 10:04 PM.

          Comment


          • #6
            Interesting point.
            I'm finally at the stage where I am not doubting the limitations of understanding. Where sometimes the answer may in fact be something in between what my logical brain can calculate and be satisfied with.
            Still looking for that tangible sense.
            sto pro veritate

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by Mbyte View Post
              everything is pointless
              How about modifying that sentence to "Everything is".

              When one door closes, another one opens.

              Comment


              • #8
                And here's the BEST PART!

                You get to make up a point as you go.

                Total freedom
                "Take a moment to feel how wonderful it feels just to be alive."
                - Sifu

                Comment


                • #9
                  Dear Sevenhills,

                  Originally posted by sevenhills
                  I think my new task is to find new equipment.
                  Take a shovel.

                  Originally posted by sevenhills View Post
                  Still looking for that tangible sense.
                  Go outside and dig hole: 120cm deep, 120cm large, 120 long. Enjoy!

                  Andrea
                  Enjoy some Wahnam Tai Chi Chuan & Qi Gong!

                  Evening Classes in Zürich
                  Weekend Classes in other Swiss locations


                  Website: www.taichichuan-wahnam.ch
                  Facebook: www.facebook.com/Taichichuan.Wahnam.ch

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    I love digging!! I genuinely cant get enough of it. I'm petitioning my friend to sort me out with an organic farm hand job.
                    I'd just do WOOFING but I need extra money coming in to pay for filming equipment extras.

                    *extra note- I didn't just go out and dig a whole by the way, in case that's how the post comes across, hehe*
                    Last edited by sevenhills; 5 October 2009, 06:24 PM.
                    sto pro veritate

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X